Skip to main content

Basil Hall, RN: Toe the Line


In the early 1802, a well-educated young man named Basil Hall joined the British Royal Navy and started traveling extensively.  His voyages were sometimes military, sometimes scientific, and he saw much more of the world than most people of his day did, or even of the modern day.  His education was encouraged by his father, who also suggested that he keep diaries of all he saw and did.  This habit had been impressed upon him when he was a boy, before he ever set sail, and he kept it up all his life.

It was quite a life to keep notes on, too.  Hall was present for a lot of the action during the Napoleonic Wars, including the Battle of Waterloo.  In 1817, two years after the wars ended, Hall had the opportunity to interview Napoleon Bonaparte himself at the deposed emperor’s home/prison on St. Helena.  He explored Korea, Japan, Java, Peru, South Africa, and other far-flung locales, making copious notes along the way.  His scientific research included rock formations in the north Atlantic, Chile, and South Africa, helping to establish the geologic record of the earth that had been begun by previous explorers (sometimes referred to as “natural philosophers” like himself, as well as by later ones to keep adding to the body of knowledge, including Charles Darwin.

It’s a small wonder that Hall contributed a great deal to the Encyclopedia Britannica.  He kept his prolific journaling habit going until he retired from the Royal Navy in 1823, at the ripe old age of 35.  At that point, he set about writing down what he saw during his career abroad.  In all he wrote eight books chronicling what he saw, several of which recollected his experience in the Navy.  It was in Hall’s memoirs that the expression “toe the line” first appears.  This comes from the military discipline that was part of naval life.  When the sailors were called to muster, they were to stand in rows on their ship’s decks.  Since navies were wooden back then, the sailors would all stand along one particular plank, on the line on the deck where two planks came together, in as perfect a row as they could.  Sometimes this was also referred to as “toeing the plank”, but it was Hall’s observation that made it into the English language.

One of Hall’s books caused considerable chafing in America.  This was Travels in North America 1827-28, which covered his experiences traveling the United States, just over fifty years old.  He called things as he saw them, which many Americans did not care for.  One of the many passages reflected on Americans’ attitudes when speaking about their country.  Here is Hall recalling conversations with Americans around Albany, New York:

We were introduced with much kindness to many persons, most of whom, the instant we were presented, began to exact our admiration of their country, their people, their institutions, all while praising every thing so highly themselves, that there was hardly room for us to slip in a word edgewise.  The praising of one’s own country, its manners and customs, in conversation with a foreigner, comes so near to praising one’s self, that the person to whom it is addressed feels a sort of awkwardness either in joining, or declining to join, in such commendations.

Persons of sense and information were, of course, above descending to such arts to extort praise, and many Americans whom I met with at Albany, and elsewhere, were fully of my opinion of the impolity of making such demands upon the admiration of their guests—but I speak of the general, average mass of society in America, the current of whose thoughts, whether flowing at the surface or beneath it, appears always to set in one direction, and prompts such expressions as the following:

“Don’t you think this is a wonderful country?  Don’t you allow that we deserve great credit for what we are doing?  Do not we resemble the Old Country much more than you expected?  Had you any idea of finding us so far advanced?”

Perhaps Hall’s book gave offense by suggesting that Americans can be braggarts.  Probably the real sin in Americans’ eyes was that he suggested that there’s a better sort of American who is more considerate and solicitous of others’ opinions and a lower sort of American who can find nothing to talk about but how impressive America and the Americans are.  Are Americans really like this?  Well, consider that I’m an American, and I have spent about half this piece talking about the part that concerns Americans.  Captain Hall might have a point.

Hall’s mental health eventually declined and he died in a mental institution at the age of 55.  The details of his mental illness are not recorded, not by Hall or anyone else who has chosen to make them public.  

Comments

Anonymous said…
This isn't displaying properly (Firefox). Each paragraph is one long line with no wrapping. :(
Kurt Kaletka said…
Anonymous - Thanks for calling my attention to that! Sometimes that happens; usually I catch it. Anyway, it's fixed now.

Thanks for reading!

-Kurt

Popular posts from this blog

Alcock and Brown: The First Transatlantic Flight

Since his celebrated landing in Paris 90 years ago, we often hear of Charles Lindbergh’s flight across the Atlantic.  He flew solo, taking off from Roosevelt Field in Brooklyn and landing in Le Bourget field in Paris after a flight of 33½ hours in his cramped, lightweight plane, The Spirit of Saint Louis.  Lindbergh was one of several individuals or teams who were competing for the Orteig Prize: a $25,000 purse offered to the first to fly from New York to Paris, offered by wealthy New York hotelier Raymond Orteig.  Lindbergh took off and landed perfectly, and managed to navigate the whole way without getting lost.  This was quite a feat in the days before computers to aid navigation, or the elaborate system of air traffic control that would come into being, once commercial airlines started to develop.  What Lindbergh did immediately made him an international hero and a household name for years after, with streets and buildings and yes, airports, named after him.  To this day, Charles …

Popeye: Casinos, Moochers, and Adventures Across the Fourth Dimension

In 1929, the plot of the daily comic strip Thimble Theater, was starting another adventure.  The plot sent one of its main characters, Castor Oyl, down to the docks of the fictional town of Sweet Haven to find transport to Dice Island, where he intended to break the bank at Fadewell’s Casino.  Castor was sure he could do it, because he’d recently acquired Bernice, a rare bird called a wiffle hen, which brings good luck when you rub her head.  To get to Dice Island, Castor needed to find a sailor, and find one he did.  Sitting by the docks was a one-eyed, tough-looking old mariner smoking a corncob pipe.  No one knew it yet, not even Elzie Segar, the strip’s creator, but Thimble Theater was about to acquire a new star.  This was the entrance of Popeye the Sailor into the strip, and into American culture.


Castor Oyl first encounters Popeye, January 17, 1929.

From the beginning, Popeye was tough.  More than tough: he was indestructible.  He could get punched, knocked on the head, and eve…