Skip to main content

The Mechanical Turk: Artificial Artificial Intelligence

One of the earliest video games made for computers was chess. It’s not hard to see why chess was chosen: the rules are pretty simple, and the game is widely played. Artificial intelligence mastered chess early on, and programmers have long been able to set chess programs to play at different levels of difficulty. The first person to suggest that a computer might play chess was the celebrated computer scientist Alan Turing. Turing started talking about this in the 1940s, and in 1950, he wrote the first computer chess program. Turing himself was a weak chess player, but he started something, and a lot of others agreed. It was a common belief that by 1970, the world chess champion would probably be a computer. This never came to pass, of course, probably because human beings still got to decide who could enter chess tournaments in 1970 (and they haven’t given up that privilege yet), and humans never let computers in. With the arguable exception of IBM’s Watson’s appearance on Jeopardy! in 2011, humans would never go down that road. In fact, they already had.

Related image
Watson on Jeopardy!, doing rather well.
Or maybe not. The first artificial intelligence purported to have played chess actually appeared in 1770. This was the creation of Hungarian inventor Kempelen Farkas. Kempelen called his invention the Automaton Chess Player, or sometimes the Mechanical Turk. It was a remarkable machine. The Turk was a large wooden box with a chessboard on top. On one side was the carved wooden figure of a Turkish man, dressed in a turban and Ottoman robes. The machine was designed to play a strong game of chess against any human who sat opposite the “Turk”. Remarkably, it did just that. By all accounts, the “Turk” was very good at what it what it was designed to do. From the beginning, Kempelen set his sights pretty high. His “Turk” was brought to the court of Empress Maria Theresa of Austria, and she was impressed. The “Turk” could perform some of the most complicated chess moves, including the knight’s tour, a move that even the best chess players will execute with difficulty. The Mechanical Turk quickly developed a reputation and toured Europe, matching wits with intellectuals and heads of state from all over. The “Turk” went on to defeat the likes of Benjamin Franklin and Napoleon Bonaparte. Kempelen himself died in 1804, but the Mechanical Turk went on defeating excellent chess players in very public exhibitions until 1854, when it was destroyed in a fire. So: how did it work? Many observers wanted to know this, and Kempelen made sure they had something to look at. The side panel of the “Turk” could open easily, and it would reveal its very complicated clockwork-like mechanism, full of gears and belts and so forth, just like you might expect to see inside a clock. It was an impressive device. But the real question, the one that we know enough to ask today, is: how can you create artificial intelligence with clockwork? The answer is actually pretty simple: you can’t. Or, at least, it remains to be seen if one day someone will, because Kempelen Farkas didn’t do it, all appearances to the contrary. The inspiration for the “Turk” came not long before he introduced it to the world. Kempelen saw a performance at Maria Theresa’s palace of the illusionist François Pelletier, and after speaking with him after the show, vowed to return with an act that would top anything Pelletier had done that evening. In short order, the Mechanical Turk appeared, and started beating chess players left and right. But it’s not quite accurate to call the “Turk” “artificial intelligence”, because there was nothing artificial about it. Inside that large box under the chessboard was artificial artificial intelligence: a human being. Yes, the whole thing was a hoax. It was a pretty good hoax, too, but that’s what happens when you don’t skimp on your resources. Kempelen didn’t put just any human being inside that box. Instead, he managed to get the greatest chess players of his day to do it.

Image result for Mechanical Turk
Artist’s illustration of the Mechanical Turk without its most important component.
The “Turk” was an immediate sensation, starting its tour of Europe soon after its debut in front of the empress. Friends and colleagues naturally wanted to see the inner workings of the machine, but Kempelen of course didn’t show them, because all they’d see was an empty box festooned with ornamental gears. They’d also be able to figure out just how it worked. The “Turk’s” chessboard was made of a thin sheet of metal, and at the bottom of the white chessmen (which the “Turk” always played) were powerful magnets. Inside the box, the human chess player had corresponding pieces, also with magnets, and he’d use them to move the chessmen around the board above. There was even a horn set up in the “Turk’s” mouth, allowing the player inside the box to speak. The only word he would speak was “Échec,” which is French for “Check”, an essential word in any chess game. Despite the popularity of the “Turk”, Kempelen was not pleased with it. He was an inventor, after all, and would rather have spent his time on his real projects: steam engines and devices to replicate human speech. The success of the hoax did raise Kempelen’s reputation, as well as line his pockets, but he wanted to get away from what he saw as a distraction. The public, and his government, wouldn’t have it, though. Even though Kempelen dismantled his device and announced its permanent retirement, Emperor Joseph II of Austria ordered him to put it back together in 1781 for an exhibition before Russia’s Grand Duke Paul. Kempelen followed orders, though he wasn’t happy about it, and the “Turk” started another European tour, one that kept on going. He tried to sell the “Turk”, but never managed to find a buyer. Following his death in 1804, Kempelen’s son sold it to Bavarian musician Johann Nepomuk Mälzel for 10,000 francs—half the price that Kempelen had been asking. Mälzel was much more of a showman than the “Turk’s” inventor was, and gladly paraded it around Europe. In 1826 he brought the “Turk” to the United States, where it also caused a sensation. Mälzel carted the “Turk” to and from Europe, traveling as far west as the Mississippi River, into Canada, and as far south as Cuba. In 1838, on his last tour of North America, Mälzel’s companion, chess master William Schlumberger, contracted yellow fever and died. Mälzel was suddenly left without the essential mechanism that makes artificial artificial intelligence work. Without a “functioning” device, Mälzel packed up the show and set sail back to Europe. On that voyage, Mälzel died at sea, leaving the “Turk” and all his possessions with the ship’s captain, who saw to it that they made their way to Mälzel’s friend, American businessman John Ohl. Ohl sold the “Turk” at auction in Philadelphia in 1840, when it was purchased by John Kearsley Mitchell, the personal physician of Edgar Allen Poe, and a great admirer of the “Turk”. Mitchell was an enthusiast of the “Turk”, perhaps inspired by Poe’s celebrated essay “Maelzel’s Chess Player”, which (incorrectly) speculated that a mechanical chess player must always win. Mitchell gave some performances of the “Turk”, but interest in the novelty waned, and he eventually donated it to the Chinese Museum in Philadelphia where it spent its time gathering dust. The “Turk” never performed again. On July 5, 1854, a fire in the Chinese Museum destroyed the “Turk”. After the fire, Mitchell said, “Through the struggling flames… the last words of our departed friend, the sternly whispered, oft repeated syllables, ‘échec! échec!” The hoax took a while to be revealed. An 1857 article in The Chess Monthly magazine explained it, stating that “no secret was ever kept as the Turk’s has been”. Following the exposure of the hoax, there were imitators who created similar chess-playing automatons. Despite the “Turk’s” secret being known, spectators were still taken in, including President Grover Cleveland in 1885. In 1984, a replica of the “Turk” was constructed for a magicians’ exhibition in Los Angeles, but by then, the public was more skeptical. Few, if any, were taken in by the spectacle. In 1985, IBM announced it was developing a chess-playing program that could challenge the world’s great chess champions. In 1989, the program Deep Thought was pitted against chess master Garry Kasparov. Kasparov beat the program, so IBM went back to the drawing board and came up with a new one called Deep Blue. Deep Blue and Kasparov met up in 1996, and Kasparov won again. But in 1997, Deep Blue beat Kasparov in a six-game match, becoming the first computer ever to defeat a reigning world chess champion. How did the programmers at IBM do it? Did they finally work out an algorithm that could challenge the greatest minds of chess? Or did they give up and just pit an empty box with another chess master inside to pit against Kasparov? They’ll never tell.

Image result for deep blue
IBM’s Deep Blue: no room to hide anyone inside that thing.


Popular posts from this blog

Betty Crocker: A Brief Biography

Long have our supermarket shelves borne products with the name Betty Crocker.  This name has long since lodged in our heads an essential part of americana.  It seems to evoke the past.  It seems to always have evoked the past, a past when life was simpler and Mother and Grandmother cooked at home, using time tested recipes and only the purest ingredients.  We can’t go back to that simpler, wholesome past, but we can give ourselves a Proustian shot of nostalgia by tasting the past we remember, or the past we only wish we could remember, but know must be so good.  That is the Betty Crocker brand.  You might have seen drawings of her, but have you ever actually seen the legend herself?  Here’s an image of Miss Crocker from a 1953 television ad:

The full "Betty Crocker" TV commercial.

Okay, that’s actually actress Adelaide Hawley, who played Betty Crocker in a number of commercials for the brand from 1949 to 1964.  Betty Crocker was born in 1921, so this representation looks to be…

The Star-Spangled Banner: The Original Lyrics

If you’re an American (and quite possibly even if you’re not), you’ve certainly heard the tune called “To Anacreon in Heaven” numerous times.  It’s a stirring melody, and can often sound very proud, and if someone asked you to hum a few bars, you probably could do a creditable job of it, even if you have no musical ability at all.  The tune is that familiar.  Of course, it has another name that you probably know better: “The Star-Spangled Banner”.

But the song’s first name was “To Anacreon in Heaven”.  The song asserts that Anacreon is in heaven, right from the first line.  Whether Anacreon actually is in heaven, I’ll take no position on, but he most certainly is dead.  Anacreon was a Greek poet who lived from circa 582 BCE to 485 BCE, which is a remarkably advanced age for the times.  Anacreon was celebrated for his songs about drinking and love and having a good time.  Maybe not the weightiest of literature, but even the most serious poets and thinkers need to take a break now and …

At, Hashtag, And Per Se

Since the invention of the typewriter in the 1860s, there has been little change to the keyboard used in English.  The position of the letters has remained the same, and the numbers and punctuation have as well. The advent of the personal computer has required additional keys, most of which have found their own standard spots on the keyboard, but for the most part, there haven’t been many changes to the original design.

If you look at the above keyboard, you can see there have been some changes. Keys for fractions don’t really exist anymore; nor does a key to write the ¢ symbol. But the ¢ key on this 1900 model typewriter also includes the @ symbol, which has been common on keyboards since the dawn of typewriters. It’s older than that, even. But of course it is: how else would anyone write an email address? Except… who are you going to email in 1900? No one was emailing anyone before 1972. That’s when programmer Ray Tomlinson invented email. He figured that if you’re going to …